Discordance of the pediatric surgeon's intraoperative assessment of pediatric appendicitis with the pathologists report

Abstract 

Background/Purpose

The nature and duration of postoperative treatment in children with appendicitis is largely defined by the surgeon's intraoperative assessment of the degree of disease. Therefore, misclassification of patients could result in either inadequate or excessive duration of treatment.

Materials/Methods

During the execution of an institutional review board–approved multicenter, randomized, prospective, single-blinded trial of laparoscopic versus open appendectomy in children, we tracked the attending pediatric surgeon's determination of the degree of appendicitis and compared it to the pathologists report. Postoperative care was determined, per protocol, by the surgeon's intraoperative classification. “Interval” appendectomies were excluded from the analysis. Statistical significance was analyzed using χ² analyses.

Results

A total of 133 patients were randomized into the open group, whereas 122 randomized to laparoscopy during the first 2 years of the study. The attending pediatric surgeons and pathologists were concordant in the determination of acute appendicitis in 90% of open patients and 93% of laparoscopic patients (P = not significant). When children were classified by the attending surgeon as having complicated appendicitis (gangrenous or ruptured), the concordance rate dropped to 38% and 52%, respectively (P = not significant). When open and laparoscopic patients were combined, the length of postoperative stay (LOS) of concordantly classified acute appendicitis patients was 35 ± 16 hours. Concordantly classified complicated appendicitis LOS was 118 ± 61 hours, and discordantly classified complicated appendicitis (pathology = acute) LOS was 85 ± 41 hours (P = .01). Wound infection rates in the concordant and discordant “complicated” appendicitis groups were 23% and 7%, respectively (P = .05).

When the surgeons are grouped as “junior”(n = 2) and “senior” (n = 3), there is a trend toward greater concordance in the latter group (P = .08).

Conclusions

In the 2 institutions studied, the 5 pediatric surgeon's intraoperative classification of appendicitis correlated with the pathologist's reading in a high percentage of those patients labeled “acute” but in only approximately one half of those defined as “complicated.” These phenomena are independent of the operative approach but may correlate with surgeon experience. Interventions to improve the timeliness of pathologic diagnosis may improve the accuracy and efficiency of care of pediatric appendicitis.

Key words: Appendicitis, Laparoscopy